Skip to Content

40 Thanksgiving Pies

Let’s be honest. Pumpkin pie is hands down the most popular pie on Thanksgiving Dinner Tables. But that’s obviously not the only option. Not everyone loves pumpkin, and sometimes you may just want some choices. We’ve put together a list of Thanksgiving pies that pair perfectly with your holiday dinner. We’re also including some vegan and gluten free options in case you’re looking for options that accommodate guests with alternative diets.

40 Thanksgiving Pies

Most of these pies can be easily prepared ahead of time, plus we have everything from classics to the amazingly creative.

Most Popular Pies By State

According to an Instacart study these are the most popular pies by state.

StateFavorite PieStateFavorite Pie
Alabama Key Lime PieNebraska Apple Pie
Alaska Lemon Meringue PieNevada Pumpkin Pie
Arizona Pumpkin PieNew Hampshire Blueberry Pie
Arkansas Chocolate PieNew Jersey Boston Cream Pie
California Pumpkin PieNew Mexico Pumpkin PIe
Colorado Peach PieNew York Boston Cream Pie
Connecticut Apple PieNorth Carolina Pecan Pie
Delaware Lemon Meringue PieNorth Dakota Banana Cream Pie
Florida Key Lime PieOhio Cherry Pie
Georgia Sweet Potato PieOklahoma Cherry Pie
Hawaii Pumpkin PieOregon Marionberry Pie
Idaho Pumpkin PiePennsylvania Apple Pie
Illinois Cherry PieRhode Island Blueberry Pie
Indiana Cherry PieSouth Carolina Key Lime Pie
Iowa Cherry PieSouth Dakota Pumpkin Pie
Kansas Cherry PieTennessee Pecan Pie
Kentucky Cherry PieTexas Pecan Pie
Louisiana Pecan PieUtah Pumpkin Pie
Maine Blueberry PieVermont Chocolate Pie
Maryland Apple PieVirginia Chocolate Pie
Massachusetts Blueberry PieWashington Marionberry Pie
Michigan Cherry PieWashington, D.C. Apple Pie
Minnesota Banana Cream PieWest Virginia Cherry Pie
Mississippi Pecan PieWisconsin Cherry Pie
Missouri Cherry PieWyoming Peach Pie
Montana Pumpkin Pie  
Monique McArthur
Latest posts by Monique McArthur (see all)